Parashat Vayeshev: What Do You Do When Both Sides Are Right?
"וישב יעקב בארץ מגורי אביו"
“Yaakov settled in the land where his father had sojourned.” (Bereishit 37:1)
The Midrash teaches: “Yaakov wished to live in tranquility, but the ordeal of Yosef sprang upon him. When tzaddikim wish to live in tranquility, Hakadosh Baruch Hu says: ‘Is it not enough for the righteous what is prepared for them in the World to Come, that they seek serenity in this world as well?’”
When we look at the conflict between the Shevatim and Yosef, it is hard to take sides. Who was right, and who was at fault?
This is especially so since, in the end, they are all the holy tribes of Hashem, and Yaakov’s family remained whole.
When Both Sides Are Right
A dispute once arose between the Netziv of Volozhin and Rav Yosef Dov Soloveitchik of Brisk over a certain matter in the running of the yeshivah. They decided to present their arguments before Rav Zev, the Maggid of Vilna, and Rav Yitzchak Elchanan Spektor of Kovno.
The two rabbanim heard the arguments and sank deep into thought.
“Do you know,” Rav Zev began, “I am now standing at Parashat Vayeshev!”
Everyone looked at him in astonishment, unable to understand what he meant. It was wintertime, and Parashat Vayeshev was still many weeks away.
“Let me explain,” said Rav Zev. “I am the maggid in Vilna, and every Shabbat I deliver a drasha in the shul. My approach in my drashot is always to contrast evil with good, the rasha with the tzaddik. In this way, I find a theme for every Shabbat of the year:
“On Shabbat Parashat Bereishit, I present Adam HaRishon against the nachash, and Kayin against Hevel.
“In Parashat Noach, the good is Noach, and the evil is the Generation of the Flood.
“In Parashat Lech Lecha, I set Avraham against Pharaoh and Nimrod.
“In Parashat Vayera, it is Avraham against Sedom and Amorah.
“In Parashat Toldot, it is Yaakov and Esav. And so, every Shabbat, I have a tzaddik and a rasha.
“But when I reach Parashat Vayeshev, Yosef and his brothers, I am at a loss. I have no tzaddik and no rasha, because Yosef and the Shevatim alike are pure tzaddikim.
“That is exactly where I find myself now, for both of you are tzaddikim and geonim, and both of you are right.”
The Lesson for Us
Heaven forbid that we should try to take sides between the Shevatim and Yosef. They are all the holy tribes of Hashem, and we have only what Chazal have taught us.