Parashat Bereishit: Who Is Right — Science or the Torah?
"בְּרֵאשִׁית בָּרָא אֱלֹקִים אֶת הַשָּׁמַיִם וְאֵת הָאָרֶץ"
"In the beginning, Hashem created the heavens and the earth." (Bereishit 1:1)
One question has occupied scientists and thinkers for centuries: How old is the world?
More than once, critics have challenged Judaism and our holy Torah, claiming that the universe has existed for millions — or even billions — of years, supporting their claims with empirical measurements. Some people even argue that centuries ago our sages lacked modern scientific instruments, questioning how the great Torah sages throughout the generations could have reached their conclusions regarding the age of the universe.
The answer, however, is simple: it all depends on the point from which you measure the world’s age.
A Parable
A king once commissioned a grand art exhibition and set a date for its opening. For an entire month, the finest sculptors and painters in the realm labored day and night to prepare their masterpieces and impress the king and his subjects.
When the long-awaited day arrived, the exhibition opened in great splendor. Two friends decided to attend and admire the creations of the country’s greatest artists.
At the entrance stood a lifelike statue of an elderly man, two meters tall, carved down to the finest wrinkle. One friend turned to the other in awe and said: “Look at the man in this sculpture — he is at least ninety years old, if not a hundred!”
His friend retorted: “Foolish man! The artists only began working a month ago, and the exhibition opened today. This statue is no more than a month old!”
Which of them is right? Both of them! The first looked at the figure depicted in the statue and estimated his age by his mature appearance, while his friend measured the age of the sculpture from the actual moment it was fashioned.
The Lesson
As Chazal teach us, Hakadosh Baruch Hu created the heavens and the earth, the seas and the mountains, the trees and even mankind, fully formed and mature in stature. He created Adam HaRishon as a grown man of twenty, not as an infant. Likewise, He formed the mountains, trees, and stones as though they had already developed over vast spans of time.
If so, what is there to wonder about? Science measures the age of the universe by how old its physical matter appears, using instruments that gauge its stage of development as it looks to the eye. The Torah and the sages of Israel, however, count the true age of the world from the actual moment of Creation — and that is fewer than six thousand years.
"משה אמת ותורתו אמת!"
Moshe is true, and his Torah is eternal truth!