Laws of Chanukah
Laws of Chanukah: Mourning During Chanukah
Eulogies (Hesped)
During the days of Chanukah, eulogies (hespedim) are not delivered (Shulchan Aruch, Orach Chaim 670:1), except for a Torah scholar (talmid chacham) at the time of the funeral itself (Mishnah Berurah 670:3). A Torah teacher of young children (melamed tinokot shel beit rabban) who sets fixed times for his own Torah study has the halachic status of a talmid chacham, and it is permitted to eulogize him at his funeral.
The Meal of Condolence (Seudat Havra’ah)
For a mourner sitting shivah during Chanukah, the initial meal of condolence (seudat havra’ah) should be served with coffee and cake rather than bread and eggs as on regular weekdays — because according to some halachic authorities, a seudat havra’ah is not held at all during Chanukah (Mishnah Berurah 670:4).
Visiting the Cemetery
- Shloshim or Conclusion of Shivah: If the seventh day (shivah) or thirtieth day (shloshim) of mourning falls during Chanukah, the mourners do not visit the cemetery, as doing so arouses weeping and lamentation; instead, they postpone the visit until after Chanukah (Kaf HaChaim 670:11).
- Yahrzeit (Annual Anniversary): If a yahrzeit falls during Chanukah and the family knows they will not be moved to weeping, they are permitted to visit the grave. However, if there is concern that visiting the cemetery will bring them to tears, they should advance their visit to a day or two before Chanukah.
Attending a Chanukah Gathering (Mesibat Chanukah)
According to Sephardic custom, a mourner within the twelve months of mourning for a father or mother is permitted to participate in a Chanukah gathering conducted in pure holiness — featuring words of Torah and sacred songs — as such a gathering is not included in the category of a festive banquet (beit mishteh) from which a mourner is prohibited (Halichot Shlomo, Chanukah 17:4).
Memorial Gatherings (Azkarah)
Even though the days of Chanukah are festive days for Israel, it is permitted to hold a memorial gathering (azkarah) during Chanukah to mark the completion of shivah, shloshim, or a yahrzeit. However, speakers must take care not to recount praises of the deceased — since eulogies are forbidden during Chanukah — and instead speak solely words of spiritual strengthening and inspiration (divrei chizuk v’hitorerut), particularly regarding the Torah education of children (chinuch habanim), as such words bring immense merit for the elevation of the soul (ilui neshamah) of the departed.
Fasting (Ta’anit)
Fasting is forbidden during the eight days of Chanukah, as they are festive days for Israel (Shulchan Aruch, Orach Chaim 670:1). Even when the yahrzeit of one’s father or mother falls during Chanukah — regarding which Maran ruled in the Shulchan Aruch (Orach Chaim 568:8) that it is proper to fast on that day — one does not fast during Chanukah. On Erev Chanukah (the twenty-fourth of Kislev), however, fasting is permitted (Shulchan Aruch 670:1).
(In our current generation, when physical constitutions have weakened and fasting carries the concern that one will diminish his Torah study, it is preferable not to fast on a yahrzeit even when it falls during the rest of the year. Rather, one should sit and immerse himself in Torah study, as the merit of Torah elevates the souls of departed parents to loftier heights than anything else — especially if one merits organizing a public Torah class [shiur] in their memory, whose spiritual value is beyond measure. However, if one works at a trade or occupation and fasting will not diminish his Torah study, it is proper to fast when a yahrzeit falls during the rest of the year.)
Chanukah Same’ach!