Laws of Chanukah
Laws of Chanukah: Lighting the Menorah in the Synagogue
The Reason for the Custom
It is customary to kindle the Chanukah lights in the synagogue with the blessings (Shulchan Aruch, Orach Chaim 671:7). Originally, when our Sages instituted the mitzvah of Chanukah lights, the enactment was to light outside at the entrance of one’s home so as to publicize the miracle (pirsumei nisa) to passersby in the street. However, when the oppression of the nations grew severe and it became dangerous to kindle lights outdoors, Jews could no longer fulfill pirsumei nisa at their doorways. In its stead, our Sages instituted lighting the Menorah in the synagogue — where multitudes gather — thereby achieving publicizing of the miracle and sanctifying Hashem’s Name before the congregation (Responsa Rivash §111; Mishnah Berurah 671:41). Furthermore, because the Chanukah lights commemorate the miracle of the Menorah in the Beit HaMikdash, they are kindled in the synagogue, which is called a mikdash me’at (a miniature Sanctuary).
Who Should Kindle the Menorah?
Publicizing the miracle must be conducted with proper honor and dignity. Therefore, it is proper that the Shaliach Tzibbur or the Rabbi of the synagogue kindle the lights — unlike those who refrain from lighting and assign a young child (katan) to light instead. Indeed, it is the personal custom of Maran HaRishon LeZion shlita to recite the blessings and kindle the Menorah in the synagogue, and afterward return home to recite the blessings again and kindle his Menorah to exempt his household.
In a synagogue where it is customary to let a young child light, one should gently and pleasantly influence them to discontinue that custom and have an adult light instead. However, if doing so might spark communal strife, one should leave them alone. Although their practice is not ideal, it is not as severe as letting a minor light at home — which must never be done under any circumstances, since at home the lighting must exempt the adult members of the household, and a minor who is exempt cannot exempt adults. In the synagogue, by contrast, the lighting is solely for pirsumei nisa and does not exempt anyone from their personal obligation.
A Mourner (Avel) in the Synagogue: A mourner sitting shivah (may Hashem spare us) who comes to the synagogue to pray should not kindle the synagogue Menorah on the first night, because doing so requires reciting Shehecheyanu, which expresses heightened joy, particularly in the presence of a large congregation. At home, however, he is certainly obligated to light and recite all the blessings (Shulchan Aruch 671:7; Mishnah Berurah 671:44).
Does Synagogue Lighting Exempt One at Home?
No one fulfills his personal obligation through the Menorah lit in the synagogue, because the mitzvah is ner ish uveto (a lamp for each man and his household), and a synagogue is not considered a person’s home (Shulchan Aruch 671:7). Consequently, whoever kindled the Menorah in the synagogue is still obligated to return home and light his own Menorah.
A Person Living Alone Who Lit in the Synagogue: If someone lives alone and was honored with kindling the Menorah in the synagogue, when he returns home to light his own Menorah, he recites only the first blessing (L’hadlik ner Chanukah), and does not repeat She’asah nissim or Shehecheyanu (Shulchan Aruch 671:7). The reason is that although one does not fulfill his candle-lighting obligation in the synagogue, several authorities maintain that She’asah nissim and Shehecheyanu are not inherently tied to the act of lighting, but are rather blessings of praise over the days of Chanukah themselves which our Sages attached to the lighting. Thus, having recited them in the synagogue, he has already fulfilled his obligation for those two blessings. By contrast, someone who has family members at home repeats all the blessings when lighting at home in order to exempt his household (Mishnah Berurah 671:45).
Time for Lighting in the Synagogue
In the synagogue, the Menorah is kindled between Minchah and Maariv (Shulchan Aruch 671:7), even if sunset has not yet arrived, provided plag haminchah (approximately 3:50 PM in winter in Eretz Yisrael) has already passed (Mishnah Berurah 671:46). The reason it is lit before Maariv is that immediately after Maariv, congregants disperse to their homes to light their own Menorahs, leaving no audience in the synagogue for pirsumei nisa.
Morning Lighting During Shacharit
It is a proper and praiseworthy custom to kindle the Chanukah lights without a blessing in the synagogue during Tefillat Shacharit in order to publicize the miracle (Mishnah Berurah 671:42). It is customary to light them upon reaching Psalm 30 (“Aromimcha Hashem ki dilitani”). An additional reason noted in the Zohar is that in the Beit HaMikdash, the Kohanim kindled the Menorah twice daily — morning and evening (see also Rambam, Hilchot Temidin U’Musafin 3:12). In commemoration of this, synagogues — being a mikdash me’at — kindle the Menorah in the morning as well.
Presence of Ten People (Minyan)
One does not recite blessings over the synagogue lighting unless at least ten people are present (Mishnah Berurah 671:44). However, even if ten are not yet present at the moment of lighting, if it is known that more congregants will arrive shortly to complete a minyan, one may kindle the Menorah with the blessings — especially when time is tight, such as on Erev Shabbat close to sunset.
- People Who Already Prayed Elsewhere: If ten people are present in the synagogue, even if four of them already prayed Maariv and heard the blessings in another synagogue, they still count toward the ten, and the Menorah is lit with the blessings.
- Congregants Who Already Lit at Home: When a congregation lights at home first and later gathers in the synagogue for a Torah class and Maariv, one person kindles the synagogue Menorah reciting only the blessing “L’hadlik ner Chanukah.” However, if at least six people present have not yet lit at home, even though the rest have already lit and recited the blessings at home, the person lighting recites all the blessings — and even someone who already lit at home is permitted to kindle it on their behalf (Mishnah Berurah 671:56).
- Erev Shabbat in the Synagogue: Similarly, whoever kindles the synagogue Menorah on Erev Shabbat (when Minchah is prayed after the community has already lit at home) recites only “L’hadlik ner Chanukah,” since the congregation has already lit at home and recited the blessings, and the synagogue lighting is solely for pirsumei nisa (Mishnah Berurah 671:56).
- Counting Women: If ten adult men are not present in the synagogue, but ten people are present together with women in the women’s section (ezrat nashim), the Menorah may be lit with the blessings, as pirsumei nisa applies to women as well (Mishnah Berurah 671:52).
- Counting Children: Similarly, if ten adults are not present, but ten are reached together with young children who have reached the age of chinuch (from age six and up, who understand the miracle of Chanukah), the Menorah may be lit with the blessings (Mishnah Berurah 671:52).
Where to Place the Synagogue Menorah & Required Oil
It is customary to place the Menorah on the southern side of the synagogue, commemorating the Menorah in the Beit HaMikdash, which stood on the south side of the Sanctuary (Shulchan Aruch 671:7). It should be placed in an elevated, prominent spot so everyone can see it.
- Orientation of the Candles: According to Maran the Shulchan Aruch (Orach Chaim 671:7), it is proper to arrange the row of candles running from east to west, so that each night’s newly added candle progresses from east (left) to west (right). Others follow the custom of arranging the row from north to south, so that the newly added candle progresses from north (left) to south (right) (Rama 671:7). Each community should follow its established custom.
- Amount of Oil in the Synagogue: In the synagogue as well, one should pour enough oil to burn for half an hour, provided people remain there during that time to see it. However, if everyone leaves for home immediately after Maariv, it suffices to pour enough oil for the duration of the prayer service, as pirsumei nisa ends once the congregation departs — and for the same reason, it is permitted to extinguish the synagogue Menorah right after Maariv (Mishnah Berurah 671:47).
Erev Shabbat and Motza’ei Shabbat in the Synagogue
Erev Shabbat: Synagogues that pray an early Minchah on Friday afternoon of Chanukah should take care to kindle the Menorah no later than ten to fifteen minutes before sunset, so as not to enter any concern of Shabbat desecration, Heaven forbid. Synagogues that pray Minchah at the regular time close to sunset should kindle the Menorah before Minchah — and in any event, no later than ten to fifteen minutes before sunset (Mishnah Berurah 679:3).
Motza’ei Shabbat: On Motza’ei Shabbat of Chanukah in the synagogue, we kindle the Chanukah lights first, and afterward recite Havdalah over wine (Shulchan Aruch, Orach Chaim 681:2).
Why do we light the Menorah before Havdalah in the synagogue, even though Havdalah is a weekly mitzvah (tadir) and Chanukah is only eight days a year?
- Delaying the Departure of Shabbat: We strive to delay Havdalah as late as possible because it formally marks the departure of Shabbat; rushing to recite Havdalah first would make it appear as though Shabbat were a burden we are eager to cast off.
- Publicizing the Miracle: The entire purpose of synagogue lighting is pirsumei nisa before the congregation. Were we to recite Havdalah first, people would immediately leave for home before seeing the Menorah. By lighting first, the congregation remains present for Havdalah while the Menorah burns.
(Note: The person lighting is permitted to strike a match before Havdalah over wine because he already recited “Atah Chonantanu” in Maariv; even if he forgot “Atah Chonantanu,” he simply says “Baruch hamavdil bein kodesh l’chol” before lighting.)
Why Is the Order Reversed at Home?: As explained earlier, at home the order is reversed: one recites Havdalah first, and afterward kindles the Chanukah lights (Shulchan Aruch 681:2). At home, the same person recites Havdalah and lights the Menorah, so lighting first would itself demonstrate his departure from Shabbat, eliminating the benefit of delaying Havdalah and restoring the rule of tadir (Havdalah first). Moreover, at home the family remains present after Havdalah, so pirsumei nisa is fully achieved afterward (Mishnah Berurah 681:3).
(In synagogues where Havdalah is not recited over wine because congregants rely on making Havdalah at home, it is proper to kindle the Menorah after “Kaddish Titkabel” of Maariv so that the congregation sees the lights for at least a brief moment before leaving — as is the custom of many Yemenite communities every night.)
The Blessing “Borei Me’orei Ha’esh”: One does not recite “Borei me’orei ha’esh” in Havdalah over the Chanukah candles, because we are not permitted to derive practical light from them, only to look at them (Shulchan Aruch, Orach Chaim 298:11). However, one may recite “Borei me’orei ha’esh” over the shamash — and once half an hour has elapsed since the Chanukah lights were kindled, since deriving benefit from their light is now permitted, one may recite “Borei me’orei ha’esh” over them as well (Mishnah Berurah 298:32).
Public Gatherings, Celebrations, and Storefronts
- Torah Events, Weddings, and Bar Mitzvahs: It is a great mitzvah to organize gatherings during Chanukah to draw the hearts of our estranged Jewish brethren closer to Torah, and to kindle Chanukah lights there with the blessings to publicize the miracle (it is best to pray Maariv there as well, giving the venue the status of a synagogue). The same applies to a banquet hall hosting a wedding or Bar Mitzvah: one may kindle the Menorah there with the blessings (Yabia Omer, Vol. VII, Orach Chaim §57; Mishnat Yaakov). Indeed, Maran HaRishon LeZion shlita personally recited all the blessings and kindled the Menorah at a major Torah awards convocation at Binyanei HaUma in Jerusalem, even after having already lit with blessings at his own home.
- Storefronts and City Entrances: In public places such as stores or at the entrance to a city, it is a great mitzvah to display burning Chanukah lights to publicize the miracle — especially where many non-observant Jews pass by who do not yet light at home, as seeing the flames awakens faith in their hearts. Nevertheless, no blessing may be recited upon kindling in such places (Mishnah Berurah 671:44).
Chanukah Same’ach!