Laws of Chanukah
Laws of Chanukah: Erev Shabbat of Chanukah
Tefillat Minchah Before Lighting
It is proper to pray Tefillat Minchah early on Friday afternoon during Chanukah so that the kindling of the Chanukah lights takes place after Minchah (Shulchan Aruch, Orach Chaim 679:1; Mishnah Berurah 679:2). The reason is that Tefillat Minchah corresponds to the Korban Tamid shel Bein Ha’arbayim (the daily afternoon continual offering) brought in the Beit HaMikdash, while kindling the Chanukah lights commemorates the miracle of the Temple Menorah. Since in the order of the Temple service the Kohanim first offered the afternoon Tamid and only afterward kindled the Menorah, we strive to mirror that exact sequence by praying Minchah first and then kindling the Chanukah lights.
Praying with a Minyan
If one cannot find an early minyan for Minchah, he should not forfeit praying with a minyan merely in order to pray Minchah early before lighting. Instead, he should kindle the Chanukah lights first and afterward go pray Minchah with a minyan (Mishnah Berurah 679:2).
The Required Amount of Oil on Erev Shabbat
On Erev Shabbat, one must pour a generous quantity of oil into the Menorah so that the lights will remain burning until at least half an hour after nightfall (tzeit hakochavim) — roughly an hour and a half in total (Shulchan Aruch 679:1). Similarly, if one lights using wax candles, he must use large, thick candles that will last for that entire duration (Mishnah Berurah 672:1).
The Time for Lighting on Erev Shabbat
If one has already prayed an early Minchah, he should kindle the Chanukah lights approximately fifteen minutes before sunset (shkiat hachamah). However, if he has not yet prayed Minchah, he should light early enough to still make it to a minyan for Minchah afterward — provided he never kindles the Menorah earlier than plag haminchah (approximately 3:50 PM during winter in Eretz Yisrael; Shulchan Aruch 679:1).
Which Comes First: Chanukah Lights or Shabbat Candles?
On Erev Shabbat, it is proper to kindle the Chanukah lights first, and afterward kindle the Shabbat candles (Shulchan Aruch 679:1).
At first glance, this appears surprising: earlier we learned the major halachic principle that whenever two mitzvot stand before us simultaneously, we precede with the more frequent mitzvah (tadir) and afterward perform the less frequent mitzvah. On Friday afternoon of Chanukah, two mitzvot stand before us:
- Kindling Shabbat candles (which occurs every week).
- Kindling Chanukah lights (which occurs only eight days a year).
Seemingly, we ought to kindle the Shabbat candles first and the Chanukah lights afterward!
However, this question hinges upon a classic halachic dispute regarding whether lighting Shabbat candles automatically ushers in Shabbat (kabbalat Shabbat):
- According to the Ba’al Halachot Gedolot (Behag), the moment a woman finishes kindling the Shabbat candles, she has immediately accepted Shabbat upon herself.
- By contrast, the vast majority of the Rishonim — including the Rambam, Ramban, Rashba, Ritva, Meiri, Ran, Rosh, Rabbeinu Shimshon, Tosafot, Sefer HaPardes, Ra’ah, Semag, Rabbeinu Yerucham, Hagahot Maimoniyot, and Maggid Mishneh — disagree, maintaining that lighting Shabbat candles has no connection to accepting Shabbat; rather, lighting is merely one of the preparations for Shabbat so that the home is illuminated in honor of Shabbat. Maran rules likewise in the Shulchan Aruch (Orach Chaim 263:4, 10) that one does not accept Shabbat through candle-lighting.
Consequently, according to the Behag, one must kindle the Chanukah lights first and the Shabbat candles afterward — because if one lit Shabbat candles first, Shabbat would already have begun, making it forbidden to kindle the Chanukah lights afterward. According to the majority of authorities who disagree with the Behag, there is no strict need to be concerned about this.
Even though the final halachah follows the majority view that candle-lighting does not usher in Shabbat — which would normally mean Shabbat candles should precede Chanukah lights due to tadir — Maran writes in his Beit Yosef (Orach Chaim 679) that one should nevertheless kindle the Chanukah lights first and Shabbat candles afterward. Why? Because even those authorities who disagree with the Behag agree that it is completely permissible to light Chanukah candles first (both because Chanukah lights carry the unique prominence of pirsumei nisa, and because Shabbat candles are ideally lit as close to Shabbat as possible so it is clear they are lit in honor of Shabbat). Since one can easily satisfy all opinions and also accommodate the view of the Behag, it is proper to do so. Thus Maran rules in the Shulchan Aruch (Orach Chaim 679:1):
“On Erev Shabbat, one kindles the Chanukah light first, and afterward the Shabbat light.”
(This order is likewise mandated according to Kabbalah.)
If One Mistakenly Lit Shabbat Candles First (Sephardic Custom): If someone erred and kindled Shabbat candles before the Chanukah lights, he (or she) may still kindle the Chanukah lights afterward (provided sunset has not yet arrived), because according to the primary halachah, kabbalat Shabbat does not depend on candle-lighting at all (Shulchan Aruch 263:10; Yalkut Yosef).
Ashkenazic Custom on Erev Shabbat
According to Ashkenazic custom, a woman who kindles Shabbat candles does automatically accept Shabbat upon herself at the moment of lighting (unless she explicitly stipulates beforehand that she does not intend to accept Shabbat with her lighting; Rama, Orach Chaim 263:10). Therefore:
- An Ashkenazic Woman Living Alone: If an Ashkenazic woman is home alone and mistakenly kindles Shabbat candles before her Chanukah lights, she may not kindle the Chanukah lights herself afterward. Instead, she should call another Jew (who has not yet accepted Shabbat) to recite the blessings and light the Menorah on her behalf, thereby fulfilling her obligation (Mishnah Berurah 679:2).
- An Ashkenazic Wife Whose Husband Is Home: If an Ashkenazic wife mistakenly lit Shabbat candles first while her husband is home, her husband is certainly permitted to kindle the Chanukah lights afterward, because her candle-lighting accepts Shabbat only for herself and not for her husband or other members of the household (Rama, Orach Chaim 263:10).
- An Unmarried Ashkenazic Man Living Alone: An unmarried Ashkenazic man living on his own who must light both Shabbat candles and Chanukah lights, and who mistakenly lit his Shabbat candles first, may still kindle his Chanukah lights afterward (before sunset). Because only Ashkenazic women have the custom to accept Shabbat through candle-lighting, whereas men do not intend to accept Shabbat at candle-lighting (accepting it instead in the synagogue upon reciting “Mizmor Shir L’Yom HaShabbat”), he remains permitted to kindle the Chanukah lights (Mishnah Berurah 263:42).
If the Menorah Goes Out Before Sunset on Erev Shabbat
If the Chanukah lights accidentally went out on Friday afternoon before sunset, strictly according to the letter of the law (min hadin) one is not obligated to relight them, as explained earlier (kavtah ein zakuk lah). Nevertheless, it is praiseworthy (hiddur) to relight them without a blessing — provided several clear minutes still remain before sunset, so that one does not come anywhere near a concern of desecrating Shabbat, Heaven forbid (Mishnah Berurah 679:3).
Chanukah Same’ach and Shabbat Shalom!