Parashat Yitro: From Morning Until Evening
"וַיֵּשֶׁב מֹשֶׁה לִשְׁפֹּט אֶת הָעָם מִן הַבֹּקֶר עַד הָעָרֶב"
“Moshe sat to judge the people from morning until evening.” (Shemot 18:13)
In a changing world, and amid competition among companies, efficiency is required. For this purpose every company hires an organizational consultant, who looks into the inner workings of the business and discovers where things or resources get stuck or go to waste.
The first organizational consultant was Yitro, Moshe’s father-in-law.
When he saw that Moshe was loading upon himself more than he could bear, he advised Moshe to establish a hierarchy and gave him thorough organizational counsel, because in his understanding Moshe would collapse if he continued in this way.
The Question
Does a rav in Yisrael need to have set hours for receiving the public?
A Story
To answer this question, a story is told of the gaon Rav Shmuel Salant, zt"l, who occupied the rabbinic seat in Jerusalem within the walls for nearly seventy years.
Alongside his wisdom and his fluency in Torah and in the ways of the world, Rav Shmuel was widely known for the simplicity of his dealings with people and for his modest way of life.
But more than anything, he impressed all the residents of Jerusalem in those days with his constant readiness to teach the law and to issue a halachic ruling to anyone who asked, at any time and at any hour.
Once, those close to Rav Shmuel asked their revered rav: “Why does the rav not set special hours of the day for receiving the public and for answering questions in halachah, as a number of other rabbis do?”
Rav Shmuel answered them in a fatherly tone: “Every Jew, and all the more so a rav and a leader in Yisrael, should strive with all his strength to walk in the ways of Hashem and to cling to His attributes. And the way of Hashem is to answer those who turn to Him at every time and at every hour.”
“We say in Birkat Hamazon: ‘For You nourish and sustain us always, every day, at every time, and at every hour.’ This implies that before Hashem, may He be blessed, there are no ‘office hours’ or chosen times at which He watches over His creatures and provides them with all their needs in life.”
“And such was the practice of Moshe Rabbeinu, who judged the people ‘from morning until evening.’ I am therefore surprised at you, that you would propose to me a new and foreign practice of setting limited days and reception hours for those who come to me.”